Skip to content
Wellsprings
buddhist-philosophyWe're still mapping where this idea was first discussed. Key passages and related ideas below.

The 'all-exists' doctrine

A major early school taught that the past and future are just as real as the present moment.

Sarvāstivāda means, literally, "the doctrine that all exists." It was one of the most important early Buddhist schools, especially in northern India and Central Asia, developing from around the 2nd century BCE. Its distinctive and controversial claim concerned time. Most of us assume the present is real while the past is gone and the future not yet here. The Sarvāstivādins disagreed: the basic constituents of reality—called dharmas, the momentary mental and physical factors into which they analyzed all experience—exist across past, present, and future alike.

Why take such a strange-sounding position? Partly to solve real problems in their system. If a past action is wholly gone, how can it still produce a result (its karmic "fruit") much later? And how can you remember or know a past object if it no longer exists in any way? By saying the factors persist through the three times—changing only in which "mode" of activity they exercise—they kept cause-and-effect and memory intelligible.

Critics, including the Theravāda tradition and later thinkers, charged that this quietly undermined impermanence, a core Buddhist teaching that everything conditioned is in constant flux. The debate was sharp enough that other schools defined themselves partly against it. Though Sarvāstivāda no longer survives as a living lineage, its vast analytical literature deeply shaped later Buddhist philosophy across Asia.

Key passages(20)

印度佛教思想史 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

Very high

印度佛學源流略講 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

Very high

說一切有部為主的論書與論師之研究 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

Very high

異部宗輪論疏述記 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

內典塵露章 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

唯識二十論述記 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

提婆菩薩傳 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

華嚴懸談會玄記 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

法華經玄贊釋 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

唯識學探源 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

性空學探源 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

冠導阿毗達磨俱舍論 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

阿毘達磨俱舍論 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

俱舍論頌疏 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

成唯識論了義燈 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

阿毘達磨順正理論 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

印度之佛教 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

原始佛教聖典之集成 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

High

天台八教大意 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

Moderate

太虛大師全書.第十六編 書評 · The Chinese Buddhist Canon (大藏經)

Moderate