The Holy / The Sacred
What makes a holy act holy — is it sacred because the gods love it, or do the gods love it because it is already sacred?
'The holy' or 'the pious' (to hosion) is the Greek idea of what is sacred, righteous, or owed to the gods. Early Greek poetry such as Hesiod (c. 700 BCE) already wrestles with what humans owe the gods, though it voices this mostly through related words like themis and dike; the term to hosion itself comes into its own in the classical age and becomes famous through Plato's dialogue Euthyphro (early 4th c. BCE), where Socrates presses the question now called the Euthyphro dilemma: is something holy because the gods love it, or do they love it because it is holy? That single question has shaped lasting debates over whether morality depends on divine command or stands on its own.
How it traveled
- HistoriesThurii (Magna Graecia) · -425explains
- History of the Peloponnesian WarAthens · -400explains
- EuthyphroAthens · -395explains
- LawsAthens · -348explains
- Theomnestus and Apollodorus Against NeaeraAthens · -322explains
- In C. VerremFormiae · -70explains
- Ab urbe conditaPadua · -27explains
- Quaestiones RomanaeChaeronea · 120explains
- Description of Greece— · 180explains
- DeipnosophistaeNaucratis · 230explains
- Ketem Paz on ZoharTzfat · 1561
- Reshit ChokhmahTzfat · 1575
- De Specialibus Legibus (lib. i‑iv)—explains
- Historical LibrarySyracuse (Sicily)explains
- The Jewish War—explains
- Legatio Ad Gaium—explains
- Jewish Antiquities—explains
- Historia RomanaRomeexplains
- Historia Ecclesiastica—explains
- De Sacrificiis Abelis Et Caini—explains
- De abstinentiaRomeexplains
- De Vita Mosis (Lib. I-II)—explains
- De Somniis (lib. i-ii)—explains
- Selecta in Psalmos [Dub.]—explains
- Suidae lexicon—explains
- In XII Prophetas—explains
- Stromata—explains
- Praeparatio Evangelica—explains
- Antiquitates RomanaeRomeexplains
- Fragmenta MoraliaAthensexplains
Key passages(20)
To the Cynic Heracleios · Julian, Emperor of Rome
Scholia in Euripidis Orestem (scholia vetera et scholia recentiora Thomae Magistri, Triclinii, Moschopuli et anonyma) · Scholia in Euripidem
Scholia in Euripidis Hecubam (scholia vetera et scholia recentiora Thomae Magistri, Triclinii, Moschopuli et anonyma) · Scholia in Euripidem