Skip to content
Wellsprings
greek-theologyfeatured in 30 works

The Holy / The Sacred

What makes a holy act holy — is it sacred because the gods love it, or do the gods love it because it is already sacred?

'The holy' or 'the pious' (to hosion) is the Greek idea of what is sacred, righteous, or owed to the gods. Early Greek poetry such as Hesiod (c. 700 BCE) already wrestles with what humans owe the gods, though it voices this mostly through related words like themis and dike; the term to hosion itself comes into its own in the classical age and becomes famous through Plato's dialogue Euthyphro (early 4th c. BCE), where Socrates presses the question now called the Euthyphro dilemma: is something holy because the gods love it, or do they love it because it is holy? That single question has shaped lasting debates over whether morality depends on divine command or stands on its own.

How it traveled

  1. Histories
    Thurii (Magna Graecia) · -425
    explains
  2. History of the Peloponnesian War
    Athens · -400
    explains
  3. Euthyphro
    Athens · -395
    explains
  4. Laws
    Athens · -348
    explains
  5. Theomnestus and Apollodorus Against Neaera
    Athens · -322
    explains
  6. In C. Verrem
    Formiae · -70
    explains
  7. Ab urbe condita
    Padua · -27
    explains
  8. Quaestiones Romanae
    Chaeronea · 120
    explains
  9. Description of Greece
    · 180
    explains
  10. Deipnosophistae
    Naucratis · 230
    explains
  11. Ketem Paz on Zohar
    Tzfat · 1561
  12. Reshit Chokhmah
    Tzfat · 1575
  13. De Specialibus Legibus (lib. i‑iv)
    explains
  14. Historical Library
    Syracuse (Sicily)
    explains
  15. The Jewish War
    explains
  16. Legatio Ad Gaium
    explains
  17. Jewish Antiquities
    explains
  18. Historia Romana
    Rome
    explains
  19. Historia Ecclesiastica
    explains
  20. De Sacrificiis Abelis Et Caini
    explains
  21. De abstinentia
    Rome
    explains
  22. De Vita Mosis (Lib. I-II)
    explains
  23. De Somniis (lib. i-ii)
    explains
  24. Selecta in Psalmos [Dub.]
    explains
  25. Suidae lexicon
    explains
  26. In XII Prophetas
    explains
  27. Stromata
    explains
  28. Praeparatio Evangelica
    explains
  29. Antiquitates Romanae
    Rome
    explains
  30. Fragmenta Moralia
    Athens
    explains

Key passages(20)

To the Cynic Heracleios · Julian, Emperor of Rome

Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high

De abstinentia · Porphyrius

Very high

Scholia in Euripidis Orestem (scholia vetera et scholia recentiora Thomae Magistri, Triclinii, Moschopuli et anonyma) · Scholia in Euripidem

Very high
Very high
Very high
Very high

Scholia in Euripidis Hecubam (scholia vetera et scholia recentiora Thomae Magistri, Triclinii, Moschopuli et anonyma) · Scholia in Euripidem

Very high